Malaysia Oversight

Our children need better protection under laws

By MalaysianInsight in April 24, 2025 – Reading time 3 minute
Our children need better protection under laws


GLOBAL Ikhwan Service and Business Holding (GISBH) on Saturday revealed that earlier there had been cases of sodomy in the organisation. 

yourinsight2020 signpost

In a video posted on the company’s social media account, company CEO Nasiruddin Ali said the cases were addressed internally as GISBH recognised them as legal offences.

It is mind boggling that the cases were addressed internally when they are offences under the law. 

Failure to make a police report about sexual crimes being committed against children is an offence under Section 19 of the Sexual Offences Against Children Act (SOACA) 2017.  

The punishment for the offence makes it a non-seizable offence. In layman’s terms, a non-seizable offence is a less serious offence. 

The Criminal Procedure Code categorises offences, among others, into seizable and non-seizable offences. This categorisation matters for the purposes of investigations. Specifically for non-seizable offences, there must be an order to investigate (OTI) from the public prosecutor or his deputy.  

The law on an investigation of non-seizable offences has been well explained in a couple of cases in the High Court. In Chan Ah Moi v Phang Wai Ann [1995] 3 MLJ 130, then-High Court Judge Abdul Malik Ishak said: “The police must first determine the nature of the offence before deciding on the next course of action. If the offence is non-seizable in nature, the police will conduct an investigation upon receipt of an order to investigate from the deputy public prosecutor. An investigation of a non-seizable offence without an order to investigate from the deputy public prosecutor would render whatever evidence collected illegal.” 

In a later case of PP v Cha Chor Kian [1998] 1 MLJ 167, then-High Court Judge Suriyadi Halim said: “For purposes of non-seizable offences, no investigation may be carried out unless ‘an order to investigate’ clearance is obtained first from the public prosecutor.” 

As to which party had the power to investigate, the learned judge said: “For non-seizable offences, no investigation may be carried out by the prosecution as it is conducted solely by the police or other lawful enforcement agencies. It is trite law that it is the police and not the prosecution who are given the powers to arrest, detain or to seize properties in an authorised manner. 

“The police whilst in the process of any investigation or carrying out of their duties will be bound by all the provisions in the Police Act 1967, Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) and the Federal Constitution, e.g. art 5(3).” 

An OTI can be said to be a pre-condition for investigating a non-seizable offence. The police cannot exercise the special powers of an investigation provided by the CPC unless and until an OTI is issued. 

The rationale for an OTI to investigate a non-seizable offence is the largely trivial nature of such offences. 

The offences under SOACA are in no way trivial. They are seizable offences – more serious offences that allow for arrest without warrant and investigation without OTI. All offences under SOACA should be made seizable offences, including the offence under Section 19.  

Failure to make a police report about sexual crimes being committed against children should not be trivial in nature. It should not be a less serious offence when the information relates to the commission of serious offences. 

A fine not exceeding RM5,000 can be just a slap on wrist for some offenders. The SOACA needs to be amended for the better protection of our children. – September 16, 2024.

* Hafiz Hassan reads The Malaysian Insight.  

* This is the opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of The Malaysian Insight. Article may be edited for brevity and clarity.





Source link

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道 Updated 58 minutes ago · Published on 25 Jul 2025 7:03PM · 0 Comments shares A Share this…

Key highlights of Budget 2025

Reinvigorating The Economy, Driving Reforms, And Prospering The RakyatCatch the 2025 Budget Tablingby Prime Minister and Finance Minister.InfographicsBelanjawan 2025fas fa-arrow-circle-right0Achievements0Focus0MeasuresBudget…
介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 | The Malaysian Insight

介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 | The Malaysian Insight

介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 Updated 8 hours ago · Published on 15 May 2025 9:06PM · 伊依斯迈尤索普指出,J-KOM所有职员均严格遵守既定规章,以专业且诚信的态度履行职责。(图:截取脸书) 社区通讯局(J-KOM)严正否认曾指示其职员在2025年人民公正党党内选举中,对特定领袖的竞选活动进行“点赞”、“分享”或“宣传”等操作。 社区通讯局总监伊依斯迈尤索普公开声明,有关该局与公正党选举存在关联的指控“毫无依据”。 他今天在面子书发帖文说:“J-KOM所有职员均严格遵守既定规章,以专业且诚信的态度履行职责。” “我在此强烈否认任何关于J-KOM参与领袖竞选活动,或被利用攻击特定领袖的指控。” 伊依斯迈尤索普曾任公正党上议员,他强调,作为通讯部下属的政府机构,J-KOM始终致力于提供准确、公正且平衡的信息,以巩固国家的民主体制与社会稳定。…
Human activity, soil erosion caused KL sinkhole, says govt

Human activity, soil erosion caused KL sinkhole, says govt

HUMAN activity and soil erosion were among the primary factors responsible for the 8m-deep sinkhole that appeared on Jalan Masjid…
Raub durian farmers hope to meet PM soon

Raub durian farmers hope to meet PM soon

DURIAN farmers in Raub, Pahang, are seeking a meeting with Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim to address claims of oppression by…