Malaysia Oversight

History, propaganda are no bedfellows

By MalaysianInsight in April 24, 2025 – Reading time 5 minute
History, propaganda are no bedfellows


DURIANS, pineapples, and now rock melons have become priorities to the Malacca government due to the demand for them from Chinese and Indian tourists. 

Whilst the state government is agog over buzzing cash registers courtesy of foreign tourists, Chief Minister Ab Rauf Yusoh has yet again been taken to task for being reckless with Malacca’s historical facts, as seen in the state’s newly erected signboards around the Unesco heritage site. 

Prior to the signboards gaffe, Tourism Malacca in July recalled the error-laden tourist guidebooks after a resident, Serge Jardin, took to Facebook to expose the agency’s incompetency.  

From the European invasion to the birth of Malacca to history of Malacca Club to Hang Li Po’s spousal status, the guidebook got it all wrong. 

Frenchman Jardin should know what he is talking about. He was a tour guide and tour agency operator in Malaysia in the 1980s before marrying a Malacca resident and settling down in the state. 

He has also written several books about Malaysia and Malacca and is rightfully acknowledged as a historian and geographer of Malacca. 

The irony is Jardin’s vast knowledge of Malacca’s historical narrative does not interest the state government. What does perturb Jardin is the lack of expertise by Tourism Malacca and related authorities in detailing the history of Malacca. 

This is the same Jardin who had called out Universiti Putra Malaysia’s “non-historian” Professor Dr Hashim Musa for “rewriting history”. 

It was Dr Hashim’s presentation entitled “Warisan Tradisi Maritim Melayu dan Teknologi Pembuatan Kapal Besar” (Heritage of Malay Maritime Traditions and Large Shipbuilding Technology) that raised red flags. 

The presentation was part of the Seminar Kapal Mendam Berahi: Realiti Atau Mitos which took place in Malacca in June last year. 

Then, Dr Hashim allegedly showed an old picture and claimed “Malacca welcomes 2,000 ships a day”, describing the greatness of the Malacca Sultanate. 

He claimed the Portuguese destroyed a mosque and spoke about the “Mendam Berahi Boat.” 

A furious Jardin pointed out that the image Dr Hashim exhibited was a picture showing the Dutch fleet while the “mosque” was actually St Paul’s Church. 

Even Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Professor Emeritus Dr Ahmad Adam was livid about Dr Hashim’s bluff. Ahmad, a historian, said the “Mendam Berahi Boat” never existed and was a figment of Hashim’s imagination. Ahmad then said Hashim was no historian and unabashedly called the latter a “Malay chauvinist”.

History is not propaganda 

Despite Jardin’s deep understanding of Malacca’s historical background, the state government continues to ignore his expertise. 

Last month, Jardin was back admonishing Tourism Malacca for refusing to buck up and assuming tourists to Malacca are illiterate. 

Jardin penned an open letter to Rauf describing the flaws found on six newly installed signboards on the perimeter of the Fort of Malacca. 

“All the signboards are illustrated with a representation of the Dutch fortification superimposed to an aerial view of today’s Hill of Malacca. If the walls and bastions are correct, the gates are wrong. Two non-existent gates have been added and one existing gate is missing,” Jardin said. 

The Malaysian Insight met up with Jardin and was left puzzled as to why the state government had no respect for his immense knowledge of Malacca’s illustrious history. 

“The tourist brochure acts like a textbook and persistent mistakes speak poorly of the government’s commitment to upholding Malacca’s precious history. 

“I cannot stand such mistakes, so I take it upon myself to fact check. The more I inspect, the more mistakes I find. The agencies do not know the difference between a ‘kota’ i.e. fort and a ‘kubu’ i.e. bastion,” he said. 

Jardin blames cronyism and nepotism for the poor state of affairs in Malacca. 

“What I am not able to forgive is the silence of the emeritus. Why do they refuse to speak up post-retirement? Why do they allow such blunders to continue?” 

Jardin’s many letters to the relevant authorities alerting them to the mistakes were never replied to. Tourism Malacca only reacted when he highlighted the problem on Facebook. 

“I wrote letters to highlight the mistakes made but no one bothered to reply. It was only through Facebook did I get them to take action.” 

Tourism Malacca top officials even turned up at Jardin’s house. 

“They wanted me to say in my Facebook post that Tourism Malacca did a very good job of dealing with the blunders. I felt it was a bit too much to ask me to do that. 

“I will help anyone who needs my assistance. But do it sincerely.” 

Jardin said it was important to have qualified people on board to ensure the sanctity of Malacca’s history remained intact. 

“I am unimpressed with the quality of people in charge, be they politicians or academicians. History is too important for politicians to leave it alone. But politicians are not historians. Universities and museums should be left alone for history to flourish. 

“When a politician uses history to serve his political agenda, it is no more history but propaganda. This is what former chief minister Ali Rustam did in 2012 when he announced a new date of birth for Malacca. 

“In 2014 it was ex-chief minister Idris Haron who gave a false impression of the Sultanate treasure in Pulau Nangka. In 2016 it was about the Majapahit city under the Malacca river and the giant bones of Pulau Upeh and in 2024 there was Rauf and the dagger of Hang Tuah.” 

Whilst no one has taken Jardin to task for speaking the truth without fear or favour, he does remain cautious.  

“History is foremost a method. New centres of interest, new questions, new sources oblige history to constantly reinvent itself.” 

The question is, does Tourism Malacca, Malacca Museum Corporation, and the state administration understand this? – September 16, 2024. 





Source link

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道

“倒安华”集会周六举行 警方宣布16条道路交通改道 Updated 58 minutes ago · Published on 25 Jul 2025 7:03PM · 0 Comments shares A Share this…

Key highlights of Budget 2025

Reinvigorating The Economy, Driving Reforms, And Prospering The RakyatCatch the 2025 Budget Tablingby Prime Minister and Finance Minister.InfographicsBelanjawan 2025fas fa-arrow-circle-right0Achievements0Focus0MeasuresBudget…
介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 | The Malaysian Insight

介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 | The Malaysian Insight

介入公正党党选? J-KOM斥指控无根据 Updated 8 hours ago · Published on 15 May 2025 9:06PM · 伊依斯迈尤索普指出,J-KOM所有职员均严格遵守既定规章,以专业且诚信的态度履行职责。(图:截取脸书) 社区通讯局(J-KOM)严正否认曾指示其职员在2025年人民公正党党内选举中,对特定领袖的竞选活动进行“点赞”、“分享”或“宣传”等操作。 社区通讯局总监伊依斯迈尤索普公开声明,有关该局与公正党选举存在关联的指控“毫无依据”。 他今天在面子书发帖文说:“J-KOM所有职员均严格遵守既定规章,以专业且诚信的态度履行职责。” “我在此强烈否认任何关于J-KOM参与领袖竞选活动,或被利用攻击特定领袖的指控。” 伊依斯迈尤索普曾任公正党上议员,他强调,作为通讯部下属的政府机构,J-KOM始终致力于提供准确、公正且平衡的信息,以巩固国家的民主体制与社会稳定。…
Human activity, soil erosion caused KL sinkhole, says govt

Human activity, soil erosion caused KL sinkhole, says govt

HUMAN activity and soil erosion were among the primary factors responsible for the 8m-deep sinkhole that appeared on Jalan Masjid…
Raub durian farmers hope to meet PM soon

Raub durian farmers hope to meet PM soon

DURIAN farmers in Raub, Pahang, are seeking a meeting with Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim to address claims of oppression by…